Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Midge's avatar

"some posts could seem a bit boring and self-obsessed, and I’m not exactly thrilled about that...

"But this is, by the way, another shitty thing about mystery illness. It’s not just the discomfort with being more vulnerable and needy, it’s the not even having an excuse for it: not a 'good' one, not one that is known."

I've noticed that much well-meaning advice directed toward the ill, especially the "unofficially" ill, amounts to, "Have you considered being less self-absorbed?"

Argh! Yes, we have! Rarely have we gotten absorbed in our frustrating selves with their frustrating problems just for kicks. The world is big and wonderful and filled with things we'd rather be absorbed in -- careers, families, hobbies... But when we can't rely on our own bodies, others can't rely on us, which unsurprisingly obligates us to focus inward, on fixing ourselves. I didn't plan to lose work to sickliness, or to be officially the mom of N kids but unofficially the mom of N + 1 because my body sometimes plays the biggest baby of the bunch. I understand others' boredom with my problems: they're not half as bored of me as I am.

"why rumination may be a common human response... Havinga built-in impulse to think back on failures and analyze what wentwrong may be a powerful aid to adaptive learning and improvement in performance. Individuals who learn from their mistakes viacontinued rumination may succeed better subsequently, and so theimpulse to ruminate after failure may have had a broad advantagein natural selection." And "If the core purpose of rumination is to discover alternatepathways to blocked goals, this would be quite useful and adaptive when goals are attainable but would remain doomed and futilewhen goals are in fact unattainable."

http://assets.csom.umn.edu/assets/166704.pdf    

Between "attainable" and "unattainable" lies uncertainty. The Big Maybe. Not knowing what's attainable. The authors distinguish helpful "action rumination" from unhelpful "state rumination", but what's the diff when the action is "gamble on resolving a poorly-understood long-term sickly state"? 

Have we tried less rumination? Less self-absorption? Yeah, probably. But, Paul... have you tried tubaquatic chakracize yet? ;-P Tuba blasts, I hear, are even more chakra-clearing underwater!

Expand full comment
Rick's avatar

So sorry, dude, really sucks. " A healthy man wants a thousand things, a sick man just one." I'm on a similar quest re: my adult son's undiagnosed leg pain. I call it Project Rabbit Hole... I take a deep breath and go down one everyday (internet)... and when I reach the next level I just see more rabbit holes to choose from...

Expand full comment
24 more comments...

No posts